On Friday, August 9th, Bomme Isago Association(BIA) gathered together a group of HIV positive women to share their experiences of violence. The workshop was coordinated by BIA but initiated and implemented by BONELA and the Her Rights Initiative.
The gathering was an opportunity for women living with HIV to explore their place in society, understand their power in the community, and discuss the specific types of violence they face as positive women.
Group work included recounting their own experiences of violence and trying to pinpoint the ways violence is directed as women living with HIV. Ms. Ann Strode, from the Her Rights Initiative pointed out that most policies addressing violence against women were written to protect negative women from becoming positive. These policies often ignore the the physical, verbal, and economic abuse perpetrated against women living with the disease.
The objective of the Her Rights Initiative is to define "violence against women living with HIV". The violence may differ or mirror the violence against women more generally, but the only way to know that is to record and compare the experiences of both categories of women. The project is taking Ms. Strode all around the SADC region as similar workshops will be held with women in South Africa, Namibia, Mozambique, Swaziland, and Lesotho. After the country workshops are completed there will be a regional conference where two representatives from each country will share their stories and exchange ideas on how to fight violence in their communities.
In the group of 20 women present at the Lobatse conversation, over half of them had experienced some form of violence. The participants told stories of being removed from their homes after they revealed their status to their mothers, and husbands and partners beating and raping them repeatedly as punishment for being HIV positive. The participants ranged from mid-twenties to late sixties and came from Lobatse, Kanye, and Molapowbojang. It was disheartening to see how many women were affected by violence and that the harshest perpetrators of the violence ranged from mothers, to cousins, to health care providers.
The last session of the workshop was an opportunity to develop an action plan. Action items included, kgotla meetings, speaking to church ministers, holding marches, and speaking to family and friends. The participants urged the workshop organizers to include men in the next conversation so as to explore the reasons they perpetrate and perpetuate this violence. In tern, the facilitator challenged the women to discuss these issues with the men in their lives; brothers, fathers, uncles, cousins, sons. She reminded them that while it may be difficult and sometimes dangerous to challenge their partners abuse, the message of ending GBV may be better received if delivered by a non-intimate partner. Therefore, sensitizing men, boys, and other women in the community should be the mandate of everyone who placed an item on the action plan. Change will come from empowered women willing to speak out against these injustices and the women in that conversation vowed to do so.
If you are currently in a violent relationship and are seeking help please contact Bomme Isago Association or the Lobatse or Woodhall police. There is help out there for you.
Health Minister, Dr Sheila Tlou this week found herself under attack from AIDS non governmental organizations for a remark she made in her World AIDS Day speech allegedly suggesting that women were deliberately infecting their children and partners with the virus.
The Botswana Network on Ethics, Law and HIV\AIDS (BONELA) and Bomme Isago, a network of women living with HIV\AIDS this week issued a press statement expressing concern “about some comments made by Health Minister Sheila Tlou during her World AIDS day Speech in Tsabong.”
Tlou said HIV positive women who fall pregnant were a challenge to zero HIV transmission. The two NGOs said they agreed with Tlou when she said the position of Government is that every citizen has the right to have children.
They were, however, disturbed by the comment that followed: “Nobody has the right to knowingly transmit HIV or knowingly expose another person – partner, spouse or child, to possible HIV infection”.
According to the press release, “this statement wrongly and discriminately suggests that women are willfully transmitting HIV to their partners and children.”
A BONELA fact finding mission conducted earlier this year found that women who know their HIV positive status before they become pregnant have difficulty accessing family planning programmes and face discrimination from many healthcare providers.
“ In order to reduce the risk of HIV transmission, all women- not only those who do not know their HIV status before getting pregnant – should have access to PMTCT services in a supportive setting,” says Christine Stegling, Director of Botswana network of Ethics, Law and HIV|AIDS. “A woman’s right to bear children should not be violated because she tests positive to HIV. Instead, Botswana should take the lead in ensuring an environment that assists women’s access to information and services to allow them to make informed and healthy choices for themselves and their children.”
The minister’s remarks are also of concern because they do not reflect the reality that many HIV positive women are not necessarily making the choice to get pregnant.
“Research has shown that in relationships, women do not have the power to negotiate safe sex. The question is, therefore, where these HIV positive women all of a sudden get the power to negotiate safer sex?” asks Grace Sedio, of Bomme Isago. “Putting the blame on women for the spread of HIV \AIDS is not part of the solution. The solution lies in us as citizens of Botswana, men and women, HIV positive and HIV negative, NGOs and government working together and not pointing fingers at one another”, she added .
BONELA is a Gaborone based non governmental organization working on ethical, legal and human rights dimensions of the HIV\AIDS pandemic in Botswana. BONELA is involved in research, training, advocacy, legal assistance and public education. Established last year, Bomme Isago Association is a growing network which boasts more than 50 members around Botswana.